The Critical Voice and the Supportive Voice complete therapy resource page

Self-Esteem & Identity · SI-08

The Critical Voice and the Supportive Voice

Listen to the tone of self-talk and try a response, action, or request for support that feels more respectful.

Developmental range: Ages 9+10-20 minutesActivityAdult professional use

For clinician-facilitated use

This is a professional resource, not a child-facing online service. A licensed clinician or other qualified adult must determine suitability, explain and adapt the activity, and supervise its use. Do not direct a child to access this webpage independently or enter client information.

Download for facilitated useView collection

An adult professional should download the full-resolution WebP, which includes margins for printing. Read the guidance below before using it.

How to use it

  1. Write or draw a self-critical message only if it feels manageable.
  2. Notice its tone, possible purpose, and effect without arguing with it.
  3. Try a more accurate and supportive response in your own words.
  4. Choose one compassionate action, boundary, or request for support—or stop here.

Questions to explore

  • What is the critical message trying to prevent or control?
  • What tone would feel believable and respectful?
  • What outside support or change is also needed?

Notes for the person facilitating

Describe the figures as visual roles, not separate beings inside the client. If externalizing language is confusing, distressing, or inconsistent with the client's experience, use a simple two-column tone comparison instead.

Ways to adapt the activity

  • Use harsh tone and supportive tone labels without characters.
  • Respond as a trusted person might, or use third-person wording.
  • Focus on a low-intensity example and omit the original critical wording.

Professional use and fit

Before using this resource, a licensed clinician or other qualified adult should decide whether it fits the person, setting, goals, accessibility needs, and applicable local policies.

Adapt, pause, or stop when the activity does not fit. This resource does not provide individualized clinical advice or replace the professional judgment of the person facilitating it.